1) Annasaheb Magar - Panyachi Kamal Chorachi Dhamal
Subject : Scarcity of water and politics around this issue.
Story : A thief has a last bottle of water left on the earth. All people on this earth are after him for his bottle. During his journey he meets a couple, a politician etc. Finally all people come together to save this earth.
Script - Average.
Direction - Average.
Acting : Above average.
Set - Minimal
Music - Above average.
Lights - Good.
Overall Rating : 5.0
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2) PICT - Mokshmulayam Putalakrupa
सर्वात घनघोर अपेक्षाभंग करणारी एकांकिका !
विषय - पुतळ्याच्या हलवण्यावरून होणारे राजकारण
प्रकाशयोजना - ठीक.
Overall Rating - 3.0
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3) DES Law College - Ahuti
Subject : Scarcity of water and politics around this issue.
Story : A thief has a last bottle of water left on the earth. All people on this earth are after him for his bottle. During his journey he meets a couple, a politician etc. Finally all people come together to save this earth.
Script - Average.
Direction - Average.
Acting : Above average.
Set - Minimal
Music - Above average.
Lights - Good.
Overall Rating : 5.0
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2) PICT - Mokshmulayam Putalakrupa
सर्वात घनघोर अपेक्षाभंग करणारी एकांकिका !
विषय - पुतळ्याच्या हलवण्यावरून होणारे राजकारण
कथा - शहरात मेट्रो रेल्वे येणार असते. ती ज्या मार्गावरून जाणार असते - त्याच्या मध्ये एका व्यक्तीचा पुतळा उभा असतो. शहरातले दोन नगरसेवक ह्या विषयावरून एकमेकांवरून खार खाऊन असतात. शेवटी दोघांच्या संगनमताने पुतळा हलवण्यात येतो. नाटकाचा शेवट एका ढिंच्याक गाण्याने होतो ज्यावर सगळे नाचताना दाखवले आहेत.
लेखन - सुमार
दिग्दर्शन - सुमार
नेपथ्य - शेवटच्या विंगेमध्ये रांगेत मांडून ठेवले होते. पुतळा हा अविभाज्य घटक होता. नेपथ्य बऱ्याच औंशी प्रतीकात्मक होते. एकंदरीत ठीक-ठाक !
अभिनय - अत्यंत सुमार
पार्श्वसंगीत - ठीक-ठाक
Overall Rating - 3.0
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3) DES Law College - Ahuti
विषय - गांधी वधाच्या पार्श्वभूमीवर गावातल्या एका अत्यंत सुस्वभावी ब्राम्हणाची होणारी वाताहत.
कथा - अत्यंत उदार - सुस्वभावी ब्राह्मणाची त्याच्या गावात खूप जास्त पत असते. पण गांधीवधानंतर गावकरी त्याचे सारे घर लुटून नेतात. पण तरीही शेवटी तो गावकऱ्यांना मदत करतो !
अभिनय - चांगला.
दिग्दर्शन - ठीक. खूप विचार केला होता असे वाटले नाही. अर्थात कथाच - एकाच पातळीवर घडत असल्याने फार काही करण्याजोगेही नव्हते.
नेपथ्य - मोजके.
पार्श्वसंगीत - खूप जास्त. भडक.
Overall Rating : 5.0 - 6.0
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pahilya 2 ekankikanvishayi na bolalech changal:).
ReplyDeleteDES chya ekankiket mhatal hot ki ghatana Ratnagiri jawal hote. Mag Malawani bhasha ka vaparali te kalale nahi. Ratnagirichi bhasha ani toning barach vegal asat. aso vaparleli malwani pan nit navati vaparli. malawani ch kaal aikalel toning mi ayushyat pahilyandach aikal. malawani saglyanich vaparan apekshit hot pan 1-2 sodlyas madhech malwani madhech gavandhal ashi bhasha vaparnyache uddisht kay hot te nahi kalal. Malwani ucchar nit navate. for example mazyakade aivaji makyakade varal(????),ahe la asa mhanatat hay nahi mhanat, kuthe la khai mhanatat. ase barech ucchar ani toning chukiche hote. Malwani madhe toningchya babtit Brahmin ani itar yat kahi farak nasato. farak ha shabdanche ucchar ani 'Na' madhe asato.
mala fakt evdhech mhanayach ahe ki jya veli apan ekhadi bhasha vaparato tyaveli apan tya bhashecha nit abhyas karane garajeche ahe. ugach vaparaychi ahe mhanun vaparnyat kahi upayog nahi.
ekandarit reviews varun ase vatate ki ya veles nehami peksha kami churas ahe...
ReplyDeletenehami peksha changalya natakanche praman ghatale ahe ase kunala vatate ka??
Girish,
ReplyDeleteNamaskar, mi Bipin Palande. Mi Modern College, shivajinagar chya 'BOYZ' ekankiketil 'Sujya'.kal annasaheb magar hya mahavidyalayane ji ekankika sadar keli tya ekankikela tu 5.0/10.0 asa rating dila ahes. ani parwa amhi jo proyog saadar kela tyala tu 4.0-4.5/5.0 asa rating dilas.mala maanya ahe ki maza 'NATAK'acha experience ani knowledge he tuzyapeksha khoop kami ahe, pan mala natak changla ka wait evdha nakki kalata.tyamule krupaya he explain kelas tar bara hoil.
p.s.-PICT ni ghor nirasha keli.tyanni je kahi saadar kela, tyabbadal tu tyanna je 3.0/10.0 asa rating dilas tyabaddal tuze abhar.
Annasaheb Magar - pahilech nahi
ReplyDeletePICT - 2.5 to 3.0 / 10
DES LAW - 5.0 to 5.5 / 10
No comments on PICT natak :( :(
I am disappointed.
@ Bipin Palande
ReplyDeleteTuza prashna atyant yogya ani tarkasangat ahe ! tyache karan sadharan ase - mi je udaharan detoy tyacha neet vichar kar -
Samaja - Tendulkar ne salag char matches madhe nirasha keli ani harbhajan ne ekhadya dusarya matches madhe half century kadhali - tar harbhajan che jast koutuk hote. pan yacha artha harbhajan tendulkar peksha changla batsman ahe ase navhe !
tumachya kalakarancha sanch khup changla ahe - annasaheb magar vidyalayala ajun natakancha anubhav nahiye ! tumhi satatyane natake pahat ahat - sadar karat ahat ! mhanun tumhi tyanchya peksha changle natak kele asale ( ani nakkich kele ahet - no doubt ) tari tumachya swatahachya kshamatela dharun tumhi natak kele ka - hyacha vichar kar. ankhin ek mhanaje - 6.0 va tyachya khalil sarvach colleges che natak sadharan hote he clear ahe ! tumhala 5.5 - 6.0 dile asate tari kay farak padala asata ?
mitra rating var jauu nakos - tumhi kadachit navatahi jaal ani ithe blog var mag ratings chya navane kadachit shankha fodal - tumhala 6 kinva tyachya var rating dilyane - maze tumachya natakabaddal mat badalanar nahiye !
Vichar kar ! ani kontihi dukhari athava hard feelings thevu nakos - bakichyanshi sod - swatahachi competition swatahashi karawi nehemi - pratyek nataka-ganik aapan THEATRE chya drushtine kiti pudhe jaat ahot - aapan kontya naveen goshti shikato ahot - hyacha vichar kar !
¬ Girish Datar
- For PICT -
ReplyDeleteI am a PICT senior. If any PICT current members are reading I AM VERY VERY MUCH DISAPPOINTED. People out there come with some expectations from PICT. PICT Team u need to work very hard , very very hard .Take all the comments positively and put up a good show next year. I hope to read some best reviews next year and All the best....
@girish samja tendulkar aani harbhajan yaa doghaanchya batting baddal jar bhaichung bhutia bolaaylaa laaglaa tar kasa vaatel re
ReplyDelete:D :D :D :D
@girish,
ReplyDeletetu mhanatos te kahi anshi patatay. pan kasa ahe ki barech loka generally sagli nataka baghat nahit, te reviews wachtat.ani jar tyanni tuza blog follow kela asel(i think barech loka follow kartat) tar tyanna asa watnar nakki ki amcha natak itar kahi(jyancha performance kharach amchya peksha changla navta)natkanpekshahi wait hota.tuzya reply warun asa watatay ki tu ekhadya college cha reputation ani past experience hyanchyashi tyancha performance compare karun rating detoys ani tuzya rating cha actual performance shi kahihi sambandha nahi.amcha asa mhanana nahiye ki tu amhala changle ratings de.tyani(tu mhanlyapramane)tuza kinwa itar konachahi mat badalnar nahiye.tu mhanatos ki rating war jau nakos.pan mag ratings cha upayog kay?
aso.........mala natkat ani tyachya RATINGS madhe tafavat janawli mhanun phakta wicharla.(tasahi)pratyekjan apapla mat mandayla mokla ahech.
ani sarwat shevti.......no hard feelings...........
ekunat ya blog ani blog writer baddal thodi samiksha.
ReplyDeletelekhan - yala lihita nakki yete.
samaj - doubtful.
reasoning - phaarach waeet.
Bhasha - ati uddhat.
review lihina hi pan ek kala ani titkich mahatwachi jababdari he kalana garajecha.
Reader's rating for the Bolg - 3.5/10