Tuesday 30 August 2011

Revised Ratings and probable plays in the final

Hello All

Thanks for reading my reviews patiently.

Today is the last day at Purushottam. Throughout the competition we experienced lot of good performances and some very innovative concepts. It's time to revise the ratings.

I can understand that there are some loop holes in previous ratings scale. But from this year's experience - having seen each and every play patiently - I can really say - how difficult judges's job is. It's really hard to have rankings and ratings and each system of rating has its own loop holes in it.

But yes - we can have a general idea of how colleges have performed this year. I welcome suggestions , comments & disagreements. But again - quality discussion is expected not the blame-game or allegations.

My intention is to have an overall idea about how colleges have performed - and this new revised rating is solely my own view - or my own opinion. It may be wrong ! Judges are more capable than me in selecting final 9 plays.  

Having said that - this new revised ratings don't include today's 3 plays - COEP, PVG Engineering and Trinity College. These three plays can change the whole scenario of the competition. :-) Best wishes to all of them ! I wish all of these colleges make judges's job very hard ! :-)  

Also I won't include MITCOE's play in this list.

Hoping your co-operation !

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ratings - I have made five main categories namely - A , AB,  B , C & Experimental category.

Category A  

1) BMCC  - Patient
2) Sinhagad Academy - Dumla
3) Cummins - Anvay

Category - Experimental

1) Dnyanganga College - Vaari
2) Sadnyapan Vibhag - Godauun

Category AB - 

1) VIIT - Emotional Locha
2) Kaweri College - Gaavgundi
3) Sinhagad College of Engineering - Hey There Delilah!  ( Comedy genre )
4) MMCC - Logging out

Category B 

1) Dhole Patil College - Teen chaaki Abhaal
2) PVG - 7.5 on Richtor Scale  ( Experimental )
3) IMCC - PL ki SRK
4)  VIT - Uttarardha
5) Sinhagad Architecture - Tutse Naaraaj Nahi Jindagi  ( * )
6) SKN College - Raajdand
7) MMCOE - saavalya
8) ILS - Catch 22

Category C 

1) MIT - Prashnachinha
2) Modern Arts Science and Commerce College - Boys
3) Indira College - Laaldastaa
4) Garware college - Aati Rahengi Bahare
5) Raamkrushna More Mahavidyalay - Navas
6) Fergusson College - Raavipaar 

19 comments:

  1. Plz correct....its Hey There Delilah!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks !

    ¬ Girish Datar

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yes, Girish, I must share this here .. Ki Judges chaa job kharach vichitra asato ... Ekhadi baab naakaaraaychee tar kaa aani sveekaaraaychee tar kaa .. chaakchuk performances pan Naatak mhanun content kaahee naahee aaNi naatak mhanun atishay genuine pan inexperience mule jaraa kamee padnaare lok yaat jaast odhaataan hote .. ekikade .. naatak seriously karoo paahaateel kinvaa karu paahaataayt tyannaa var dharaava ki je sansanit kaaheehee (te kaaheehee asel taree) saadar karataayt tyaanaa asa ek virodhaabhaas manaat asatoch .. pan to hee baajulaa thevoon, aapalyaa ''konatyaahee agenda' laa maage sarkaavanyaacha kaam phaar vichitra asata .. mee jevhaa jevhaa spardhet tyaa jaagee hoto tevha tevha mee malaa prekshak mhanun aattaa kaay hotay tech aani tvhadhach mahatvaacha maanat aalo .. He malaa ithe bolaava asa vaatala kaaran tu tujhee badalalelee ranking system .. incidentally tee mee parikshak mhanun basalyaavar mee vaaparato tyaachyaa baryapaikee javalachee vaatalee mhanun mee he share kartoy. Well .. I categorize performances in to C, C+, C++, B-, B, B+, B++, A and A+ .. A++ generally nasatach koni ... mag ekekaa category madhe daava-ujava karat nikaal baryaapaikee laavataa yeto .. Aso .. mee sarva ekaankikaa paahu shakalo naahee tyaamule mee ranking deu shakat naahee .. pan maajhyaa sehjaaree roj basanaryaa tujhyaa rankings mule kaahee kalpanaa yete aahe .. Thanks !

    ReplyDelete
  4. sr. P.V.G(7.5 on Richtor Scale ) cha Natk tumhi "B" Group madhe taklay...It's Ok.... Pan bracket madhe "Experimental" asa ka lihilay??

    ReplyDelete
  5. Experimental cha kai kalala nai mala

    ReplyDelete
  6. Great work with the reviews. Just a question - What does the (*) in front of Sinhgad Architecture stand for??

    ReplyDelete
  7. Girish, thnks for the reviews...
    u were almost there........

    ReplyDelete
  8. d final list is out..
    d thng i hav 2 ask is dat 'fakta navajlelya colgs lach final 9 madhe select kartat ka?? for eg... me dhole patil colg che natak pahile,,, itz wuz jus awsum bt it hs nt ben selectd n viit cha natak waz nt dat impressive compard to dhole patil,,, tar mag asa result ka???'

    ReplyDelete
  9. @Anonymous
    Rock Band Singer
    and
    Classical Singer
    Parikshakana donhi baghava lagta....ani prekshak je avdto te baghto

    Tar 9tle je select zale te tase aahet ....cheers :)

    ReplyDelete
  10. parikshakancha resultshi girish da che analysis 70 te 80 takke match hote

    cograts girish da

    ReplyDelete
  11. he atta final 9 che barik sarik mudde review chya rupane lihiles tar pharach awadel

    ReplyDelete
  12. 3o tarkheche review??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

    ReplyDelete
  13. all result are already fixed , because in this compilation only check the name and which college is perform and then set the Number .If you write XYZ natak is not good they are not performed good , how they can selected .........
    I don't belive This kind of Compilation ,This is My point of view .

    ReplyDelete
  14. ^^ warcha anonymous, nemka kai mhanaicha tumhala ? kalatach nahiye !! aapla natak lokanna avadla nahi- mhanun lokanna shivya ghalnyapeksha aapla natak nemka kuthe kami padla ani tyat kai sudharna karta yeil - asa prayatna kela tar, ya spardhetun kahi tari gheun gelat- asa hoil. spardha mhanje bakshish navhe ho - process madhun tumhi kiti pudhe jataet he mahatvacha ! asa majha tari mat ahe bua !

    ReplyDelete
  15. dnyanganga ani kaweri var saral saral anyay ahe...
    viit cha yanchya samor khup ghaan zala hota... aaj paryant vatat hota ki fakt Firodiya ch biased ahe... purushottam la pan asa hot asel asa vatala navhata... :(

    ReplyDelete
  16. Please upload the reviews for the shows performed on 30th!! We all are eagerly waiting over here.

    ReplyDelete
  17. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete